DocsRole matrix after ADR 010
The role matrix before ADR 010 with one more column: the
role that resolves on the child under the rules of
ADR 010. Both columns were produced by the role handler,
“Result before” by develop at c5c5650eda and “New result” by the branch implementing
the record. A new result that differs from the result before is marked “(new)” and shown
in bold; 70 of the 343 combinations of direct roles change, and 3 of the 18 rows with a
team.
How to read it
- The child is a table of a database. A view below a table follows the same rules one level down. Automations, application builders and dashboards have no scopes below the application.
- A role is held by the member themselves unless it is marked “(team)”: then a team the member belongs to holds it. “–” means no role assignment on that scope.
- The workspace role is the one stored on the membership. “No role” makes the member take the roles of their teams on the workspace instead.
- The result is the role that applies on the child, which is what decides what the member can do there.
- Builder, Editor, Commenter and Viewer resolve the same way; the rows differ only in which of them comes out.
Every combination of direct roles
| Workspace role | Application role | Child role | Result before | New result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Admin | – | – | Admin | Admin |
| Admin | – | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Admin | – | Builder | Builder | Admin (new) |
| Admin | – | Editor | Editor | Admin (new) |
| Admin | – | Commenter | Commenter | Admin (new) |
| Admin | – | Viewer | Viewer | Admin (new) |
| Admin | – | No access | No access | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Admin | – | Admin | Admin |
| Admin | Admin | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Admin | Admin | Builder | Builder | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Admin | Editor | Editor | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Admin | Commenter | Commenter | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Admin | Viewer | Viewer | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Admin | No access | No access | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Builder | – | Builder | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Builder | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Admin | Builder | Builder | Builder | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Builder | Editor | Editor | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Builder | Commenter | Commenter | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Builder | Viewer | Viewer | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Builder | No access | No access | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Editor | – | Editor | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Editor | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Admin | Editor | Builder | Builder | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Editor | Editor | Editor | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Editor | Commenter | Commenter | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Editor | Viewer | Viewer | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Editor | No access | No access | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Commenter | – | Commenter | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Commenter | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Admin | Commenter | Builder | Builder | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Commenter | Editor | Editor | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Commenter | Viewer | Viewer | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Commenter | No access | No access | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Viewer | – | Viewer | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Viewer | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Admin | Viewer | Builder | Builder | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Viewer | Editor | Editor | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Viewer | Commenter | Commenter | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer | Admin (new) |
| Admin | Viewer | No access | No access | Admin (new) |
| Admin | No access | – | No access | Admin (new) |
| Admin | No access | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Admin | No access | Builder | Builder | Admin (new) |
| Admin | No access | Editor | Editor | Admin (new) |
| Admin | No access | Commenter | Commenter | Admin (new) |
| Admin | No access | Viewer | Viewer | Admin (new) |
| Admin | No access | No access | No access | Admin (new) |
| Builder | – | – | Builder | Builder |
| Builder | – | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Builder | – | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| Builder | – | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| Builder | – | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| Builder | – | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| Builder | – | No access | No access | No access |
| Builder | Admin | – | Admin | Admin |
| Builder | Admin | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Builder | Admin | Builder | Builder | Admin (new) |
| Builder | Admin | Editor | Editor | Admin (new) |
| Builder | Admin | Commenter | Commenter | Admin (new) |
| Builder | Admin | Viewer | Viewer | Admin (new) |
| Builder | Admin | No access | No access | Admin (new) |
| Builder | Builder | – | Builder | Builder |
| Builder | Builder | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Builder | Builder | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| Builder | Builder | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| Builder | Builder | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| Builder | Builder | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| Builder | Builder | No access | No access | No access |
| Builder | Editor | – | Editor | Editor |
| Builder | Editor | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Builder | Editor | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| Builder | Editor | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| Builder | Editor | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| Builder | Editor | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| Builder | Editor | No access | No access | No access |
| Builder | Commenter | – | Commenter | Commenter |
| Builder | Commenter | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Builder | Commenter | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| Builder | Commenter | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| Builder | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| Builder | Commenter | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| Builder | Commenter | No access | No access | No access |
| Builder | Viewer | – | Viewer | Viewer |
| Builder | Viewer | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Builder | Viewer | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| Builder | Viewer | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| Builder | Viewer | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| Builder | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| Builder | Viewer | No access | No access | No access |
| Builder | No access | – | No access | No access |
| Builder | No access | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Builder | No access | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| Builder | No access | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| Builder | No access | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| Builder | No access | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| Builder | No access | No access | No access | No access |
| Editor | – | – | Editor | Editor |
| Editor | – | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Editor | – | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| Editor | – | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| Editor | – | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| Editor | – | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| Editor | – | No access | No access | No access |
| Editor | Admin | – | Admin | Admin |
| Editor | Admin | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Editor | Admin | Builder | Builder | Admin (new) |
| Editor | Admin | Editor | Editor | Admin (new) |
| Editor | Admin | Commenter | Commenter | Admin (new) |
| Editor | Admin | Viewer | Viewer | Admin (new) |
| Editor | Admin | No access | No access | Admin (new) |
| Editor | Builder | – | Builder | Builder |
| Editor | Builder | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Editor | Builder | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| Editor | Builder | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| Editor | Builder | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| Editor | Builder | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| Editor | Builder | No access | No access | No access |
| Editor | Editor | – | Editor | Editor |
| Editor | Editor | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Editor | Editor | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| Editor | Editor | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| Editor | Editor | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| Editor | Editor | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| Editor | Editor | No access | No access | No access |
| Editor | Commenter | – | Commenter | Commenter |
| Editor | Commenter | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Editor | Commenter | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| Editor | Commenter | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| Editor | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| Editor | Commenter | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| Editor | Commenter | No access | No access | No access |
| Editor | Viewer | – | Viewer | Viewer |
| Editor | Viewer | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Editor | Viewer | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| Editor | Viewer | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| Editor | Viewer | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| Editor | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| Editor | Viewer | No access | No access | No access |
| Editor | No access | – | No access | No access |
| Editor | No access | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Editor | No access | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| Editor | No access | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| Editor | No access | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| Editor | No access | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| Editor | No access | No access | No access | No access |
| Commenter | – | – | Commenter | Commenter |
| Commenter | – | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Commenter | – | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| Commenter | – | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| Commenter | – | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| Commenter | – | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| Commenter | – | No access | No access | No access |
| Commenter | Admin | – | Admin | Admin |
| Commenter | Admin | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Commenter | Admin | Builder | Builder | Admin (new) |
| Commenter | Admin | Editor | Editor | Admin (new) |
| Commenter | Admin | Commenter | Commenter | Admin (new) |
| Commenter | Admin | Viewer | Viewer | Admin (new) |
| Commenter | Admin | No access | No access | Admin (new) |
| Commenter | Builder | – | Builder | Builder |
| Commenter | Builder | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Commenter | Builder | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| Commenter | Builder | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| Commenter | Builder | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| Commenter | Builder | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| Commenter | Builder | No access | No access | No access |
| Commenter | Editor | – | Editor | Editor |
| Commenter | Editor | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Commenter | Editor | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| Commenter | Editor | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| Commenter | Editor | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| Commenter | Editor | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| Commenter | Editor | No access | No access | No access |
| Commenter | Commenter | – | Commenter | Commenter |
| Commenter | Commenter | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Commenter | Commenter | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| Commenter | Commenter | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| Commenter | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| Commenter | Commenter | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| Commenter | Commenter | No access | No access | No access |
| Commenter | Viewer | – | Viewer | Viewer |
| Commenter | Viewer | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Commenter | Viewer | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| Commenter | Viewer | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| Commenter | Viewer | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| Commenter | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| Commenter | Viewer | No access | No access | No access |
| Commenter | No access | – | No access | No access |
| Commenter | No access | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Commenter | No access | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| Commenter | No access | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| Commenter | No access | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| Commenter | No access | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| Commenter | No access | No access | No access | No access |
| Viewer | – | – | Viewer | Viewer |
| Viewer | – | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Viewer | – | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| Viewer | – | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| Viewer | – | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| Viewer | – | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| Viewer | – | No access | No access | No access |
| Viewer | Admin | – | Admin | Admin |
| Viewer | Admin | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Viewer | Admin | Builder | Builder | Admin (new) |
| Viewer | Admin | Editor | Editor | Admin (new) |
| Viewer | Admin | Commenter | Commenter | Admin (new) |
| Viewer | Admin | Viewer | Viewer | Admin (new) |
| Viewer | Admin | No access | No access | Admin (new) |
| Viewer | Builder | – | Builder | Builder |
| Viewer | Builder | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Viewer | Builder | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| Viewer | Builder | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| Viewer | Builder | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| Viewer | Builder | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| Viewer | Builder | No access | No access | No access |
| Viewer | Editor | – | Editor | Editor |
| Viewer | Editor | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Viewer | Editor | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| Viewer | Editor | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| Viewer | Editor | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| Viewer | Editor | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| Viewer | Editor | No access | No access | No access |
| Viewer | Commenter | – | Commenter | Commenter |
| Viewer | Commenter | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Viewer | Commenter | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| Viewer | Commenter | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| Viewer | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| Viewer | Commenter | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| Viewer | Commenter | No access | No access | No access |
| Viewer | Viewer | – | Viewer | Viewer |
| Viewer | Viewer | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Viewer | Viewer | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| Viewer | Viewer | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| Viewer | Viewer | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| Viewer | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| Viewer | Viewer | No access | No access | No access |
| Viewer | No access | – | No access | No access |
| Viewer | No access | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| Viewer | No access | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| Viewer | No access | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| Viewer | No access | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| Viewer | No access | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| Viewer | No access | No access | No access | No access |
| No access | – | – | No access | No access |
| No access | – | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| No access | – | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| No access | – | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| No access | – | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| No access | – | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| No access | – | No access | No access | No access |
| No access | Admin | – | Admin | Admin |
| No access | Admin | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| No access | Admin | Builder | Builder | Admin (new) |
| No access | Admin | Editor | Editor | Admin (new) |
| No access | Admin | Commenter | Commenter | Admin (new) |
| No access | Admin | Viewer | Viewer | Admin (new) |
| No access | Admin | No access | No access | Admin (new) |
| No access | Builder | – | Builder | Builder |
| No access | Builder | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| No access | Builder | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| No access | Builder | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| No access | Builder | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| No access | Builder | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| No access | Builder | No access | No access | No access |
| No access | Editor | – | Editor | Editor |
| No access | Editor | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| No access | Editor | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| No access | Editor | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| No access | Editor | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| No access | Editor | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| No access | Editor | No access | No access | No access |
| No access | Commenter | – | Commenter | Commenter |
| No access | Commenter | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| No access | Commenter | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| No access | Commenter | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| No access | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| No access | Commenter | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| No access | Commenter | No access | No access | No access |
| No access | Viewer | – | Viewer | Viewer |
| No access | Viewer | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| No access | Viewer | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| No access | Viewer | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| No access | Viewer | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| No access | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| No access | Viewer | No access | No access | No access |
| No access | No access | – | No access | No access |
| No access | No access | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| No access | No access | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| No access | No access | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| No access | No access | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| No access | No access | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| No access | No access | No access | No access | No access |
| No role | – | – | No access | No access |
| No role | – | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| No role | – | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| No role | – | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| No role | – | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| No role | – | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| No role | – | No access | No access | No access |
| No role | Admin | – | Admin | Admin |
| No role | Admin | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| No role | Admin | Builder | Builder | Admin (new) |
| No role | Admin | Editor | Editor | Admin (new) |
| No role | Admin | Commenter | Commenter | Admin (new) |
| No role | Admin | Viewer | Viewer | Admin (new) |
| No role | Admin | No access | No access | Admin (new) |
| No role | Builder | – | Builder | Builder |
| No role | Builder | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| No role | Builder | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| No role | Builder | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| No role | Builder | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| No role | Builder | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| No role | Builder | No access | No access | No access |
| No role | Editor | – | Editor | Editor |
| No role | Editor | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| No role | Editor | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| No role | Editor | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| No role | Editor | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| No role | Editor | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| No role | Editor | No access | No access | No access |
| No role | Commenter | – | Commenter | Commenter |
| No role | Commenter | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| No role | Commenter | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| No role | Commenter | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| No role | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| No role | Commenter | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| No role | Commenter | No access | No access | No access |
| No role | Viewer | – | Viewer | Viewer |
| No role | Viewer | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| No role | Viewer | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| No role | Viewer | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| No role | Viewer | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| No role | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| No role | Viewer | No access | No access | No access |
| No role | No access | – | No access | No access |
| No role | No access | Admin | Admin | Admin |
| No role | No access | Builder | Builder | Builder |
| No role | No access | Editor | Editor | Editor |
| No role | No access | Commenter | Commenter | Commenter |
| No role | No access | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| No role | No access | No access | No access | No access |
Roles held through a team
A team can hold a role on the workspace too, which applies to the members whose stored role is “No role”. A team’s Admin is not held directly, so it gets no precedence: a role on a scope inside still wins, on the workspace as on an application.
| Workspace role | Application role | Child role | Result before | New result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| No role, Admin (team) | – | – | Admin | Admin |
| No role, Admin (team) | – | No access | No access | No access |
| No role, Editor (team) | – | – | Editor | Editor |
| No role, Editor (team) | – | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| Editor, Admin (team) | – | – | Editor | Editor |
| Editor, Admin (team) | – | No access | No access | No access |
| Admin | – | No access (team) | No access | Admin (new) |
| Admin | No access (team) | – | No access | Admin (new) |
| Editor | Admin (team) | – | Admin | Admin |
| Editor | Admin (team) | Viewer | Viewer | Viewer |
| Editor | Admin (team) | No access (team) | No access | No access |
| Editor | Viewer, Admin (team) | – | Viewer | Viewer |
| Editor | Admin, No access (team) | – | Admin | Admin |
| Editor | Admin | No access (team) | No access | Admin (new) |
| Viewer | – | Viewer, Admin (team) | Viewer | Viewer |
| Viewer | – | Admin, Viewer (team) | Admin | Admin |
| No access | Editor (team) | – | Editor | Editor |
| No access | – | Editor (team) | Editor | Editor |